Princess Anne, Part 2: Revenge of the Crying Tomato


A marker outside the Virginia Beach courthouse.

A brief note from our sponsors…

Princess Anne, part 1, was brought to you by a pot of coffee in the middle of the night and a cat who kept waking me up by sleeping on my face.  Princess Anne, part 2, is sponsored by cheap wine from Lidl and some really tasty gouda cheese crackers.

It’s time for a quick recap.

In Part 1, Anne Stuart is born and spends her childhood imitating a crying tomato.  Her uncle, King Charles II, dies with no heirs, making Anne’s father King James II.  Anne gets married to a kindly anti-Viking from Denmark.  James’ flirtation with Catholicism gets him forcibly removed from the English throne after only 3 years.  Anne’s sister and brother-in-law ascend the throne in his place, and Anne becomes the new heir presumptive to the crown of England.  Not bad for being born a woman in early modern Europe, eh?

Here’s part 2.

A Waiting Game

Anne Stuart was extremely popular in the 1690s.  She was expected to replace William and Mary as Queen of England one day, and that made her top of mind in Virginia throughout the last days of the 17th century.

In 1691, a very large Lower Norfolk County in southeast Virginia was split in two pieces.  One part became Norfolk County (eventually Chesapeake), the other part became Princess Anne County – the precursor of Virginia Beach.

Many other American places were named for Anne around the same time, especially in Maryland and Virginia.  (Annapolis, anyone?)

Aside from her newfound popularity, Anne spent the 1690s mostly removed from politics.  Despite her status as heir, the co-monarchs William and Mary didn’t really include Anne in the decision making of the realm.

Anne and her husband George had a quiet life in London with their only living son, George.  Anne was still struggling with miscarriages and stillbirths, of which there were at least ten between 1689 and 1700.

Friends said there was nothing more moving than to see the Queen and her husband mourning together as the little coffins mounted up.  Sometimes they would weep together.  Other times they just sat in silence hand in hand.  It was unimaginably awful.  To this day, no one really agrees on the reason behind [Anne’s fertility struggles].5

Despite the horror at home, Anne was known for her charm, her obstinacy, her fun-loving spirit, and her weight.  Her statue sits outside St. Paul’s Cathedral in London; a contemporary commented “it was fitting she was depicted with her rump to the church, gazing longingly into a wineshop.”6

She sounds like a good time.

Queen at Last

Anne’s sister Mary died in 1694.  Mary’s husband William died in 1702 in a riding accident. William wasn’t a well-loved King.  More than a few of his subjects were spotted saluting the horse that toppled him.7

Does anyone remember Mr. Ed? Imagine if he were King William’s horse. “I’ve had enough of your shit Willy. Also, I can time travel. Peace!”

Anne became the first Queen Regnant since Elizabeth I.  This was somewhat controversial, and not for the reasons you might think: Government ministers worried that when the time came, her chronic ill health would make her physically incapable of the job.  To 17th century eyes, Anne was gigantic – both in height and weight.  Whether because of her weight, or her reported gout, Anne’s joints were in constant pain.8  Her mobility was so bad that she hobbled around Kensington Palace in a sedan chair.

Accordingly, the new queen’s ministers were fearful of being at the mercy of a sickly woman.  They soon realized there was no reason to worry.  Shortly after her “Sunshine Day” of ascension, Anne appeared before Parliament for the first time.  She was a smash.

According to one eyewitness, “Never any woman spoke more audibly or with better grace.”…  [She was] resplendent.  She wore the crown, the star and garter, and a magnificent gown of red velvet lined with ermine and edged with gold galloon.9


King Charles II of Spain. His family tree was a collection on spoons instead of forks. His autopsy says his body “did not contain a single drop of blood; his heart was the size of a peppercorn; his lungs corroded; his intestines rotten and gangrenous; he had a single testicle, black as coal, and his head was full of water.”12 And these people LIKED HIM.

Her lifelong rosacea was interpreted as bashfulness, which the Parliamentarians viewed as especially charming.10  After giving a heartfelt speech about her loyalty to England and her wishes for the prosperity of its people, she was compared to Elizabeth I.11

It was good that Parliament adored her.  She was about to experience her first trial by fire.

How to Go to War in 60 Days

Only 2 months after Anne became queen, Europe erupted in war.  After years of baffling Christendom by continuing to live, the inbred King of Spain had died childless.  His closest heir was also an heir to the French throne – creating the terrifying possibility of a new European Empire.

England, Holland, and Austria fought together to prevent France and Spain from forming this new, Super-Catholic Superpower.  The War of the Spanish Succession was one of the first world wars, and it dominated the rest of Anne’s reign until finally being settled in 1714.

Anne – who had never demonstrated any interest nor aptitude for warfare – now found herself trying to lead an army.

She chose the best possible route: she delegated the war effort to people who knew what they were doing.  She consulted experienced admirals, generals, and diplomats.13  Soon, the British were winning victories.

This became the hallmark of Anne’s ruling style.  She knew that her own experience was too limited, so she found and listened to subject matter experts and made decisions based on their recommendations.
In Part 3, Queen Anne settles the succession on a distant German prince and united England and Scotland under one flag.

5 “Stuarts to Hanoverians.”  Fit To Rule: How Royal Illness Changed History, series 1, episode 2, BBC Two, April 2013.  Youtube,

Somerset, Anne (2012). Queen Anne: The Politics of Passion. London: HarperCollins.

7 “Stuarts to Hanoverians.”  Fit To Rule: How Royal Illness Changed History, series 1, episode 2, BBC Two, April 2013.  Youtube,

8 Saxbe, W. B. Jr.  “LISTERIA MONOCYTOGENES AND QUEEN ANNE.”  Pediatrics, vol. 49, no. 1, 1972. American Academy of Pediatrics News Gateway

9 Bucholz, R.O. (1993).  The Augustan Court: Queen Anne and the Decline of Court Culture. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.

10  Possibly the best moment in the History of Rosacea.

11  Green, David (1970). Queen Anne. London: Collins.

12  Gargarilla, Pedro. “Enfermedades de los reyes de España. Los Austrias : de la locura de Juana a la impotencia de Carlos II el Hechizado” La Esfera de los Libros S.L., 2005.

13  John B. Hattendorf, “English Governmental Machinery and the Conduct of War, 1702–1713.” War & Society 3.2 (1985): 1-22.


Curtis, Gila; introduced by Antonia Fraser (1972). The Life and Times of Queen Anne. London: Weidenfeld & Nicolson.


Witchduck Road and Grace Sherwood

I would be a total idiot if I did not include the story of Grace Sherwood, the Witch of Pungo, and the reason for Witchduck Road.

The story about Grace is a lot like Kool-Aid:  You have your bright purple sugar packet and a pitcher of water.  The water is the truth; the sugar is all the legends and embellishments and lies.  After you mix the two together, you get something totally new…  And something that can never really be divided again into its component parts, no matter how hard you try.  Most of what I’m about to say is a big ole pitcher of Purple Drank, because we have no way to know otherwise.

You’ve been warned.


If you’re not from Virginia Beach, let me bring you up to speed:  in 1705, a woman named Grace Sherwood was accused of witchcraft.  The court ordered her to be bound and thrown into the Lynnhaven River.  She survived, and lived a quiet life thereafter.

The little dirt track that lead to her dunking site became forever after known as Witchduck Road.  The modern day site of her ducking is now a neighborhood called Witchduck Point.

If you’re looking closely, you can see little markers of her existence scattered around the city.  There’s a statue in her honor outside the old Bayside Hospital.  There’s a marker about her life somewhere on Princess Anne Road.  The foundations of her homestead are still here, but overgrown somewhere in Back Bay National Wildlife Refuge.

That’s the verified truth about Grace.  Let’s dive into the rest.

🎵🎵 How Do You Solve a Problem Like Grace Sherwood🎵🎵

🎵How do you catch a witch and duck her down?🎵

Statue of Grace Sherwood outside of the old Bayside Hospital.

She was born in Princess Anne County in 1660.  She married in 1680 and had a small farm.  She was born here, she was married here, she lived her entire life here, and she died here.  But more importantly…

Grace Sherwood annoyed the hell out of her neighbors.

From the 1690s onwards, Grace was in and out of court constantly.  She was accused of killing livestock.  Hexing cotton crops.  Spiritual assaults.  People thought she could teleport through keyholes.  On one occasion, someone claimed she turned herself into a tiny black cat with a whip and whipped them out of their bed.2  (I guess the origins of BDSM are older than I thought.)     

What surprises me most about these accusations is that the local courts apparently saw them for what they were: a way to harass another citizen without much proof.  Where the records still exist, they show that her accusers’ cases were quickly dismissed, or the courts chose not to deliver decisions.3   This, I suppose, is the legalese way of shrugging and saying “PPFFTTTT. WHATEVER.”

After each of these accusations, Grace counter-sued her accuser for defamation.  She often won.  These cases were also resolved quickly.

Late in 1705, Grace’s neighbor Elizabeth Hill attacked Grace.  Grace immediately had her up on charges for assault and battery, and asked for restitution. In December of 1705, Grace won a judgement for 20 shillings – that’s about $250 in today’s money.

After losing their case, the Hills fought back immediately.  Late in December of 1705, they told the court that Grace had used witchcraft to cause Elizabeth Hill to have a miscarriage.4

This is the point where everything escalates out of control.

Time Out

All of Grace’s previous cases had been resolved quickly.  Why was this time different?  Why did the court treat it so seriously?  Why couldn’t the Hill family let this go?  

Let’s imagine that we are Grace Sherwood’s neighbor.  

Grace had a nasty relationship with Luke Hill.  Maybe she pooped in his yard, or yelled at somebody’s kid to get off her lawn.  Then Grace and Elizabeth got into a fistfight.  It was the last straw, and I can easily imagine her accuser screaming in Honeymooners style “So help me God Luke, if that woman bothers us ONE MORE TIME, I swear I will call out a warrant for witchcraft.  ONE MORE TIME!”

But her angry neighbors had a hurdle.  Many had accused Grace of witchcraft before and failed.  They certainly couldn’t run to the sheriff and whine about a Phantom Pooper.  They had to have a charge that would finally turn other people against her.  Something that would stick.  So how do you get the authorities to take you seriously and finally take action once and for all?

You allege an unprovable murder. 6

The previous accusations of witchcraft were fundamentally different.  The damages suffered seemed more temporary.  The court could easily tell Grace’s accusers to buy another cow.  Wait for another piglet to be born.  Grow another field of wheat.

The court could not replace Mrs. Hill’s lost baby.

After Time Out, I’ll show that the Hill family hounded Grace Sherwood through the legal system, making sure the case stayed alive after the local court tried to drop it, and even petitioning the Governor to get involved. 

Why couldn’t the Hill family let this go?  Simple: they were out for blood.

The Not-Trial of Grace Sherwood

The oldest records available about Grace Sherwood’s ordeal are the Princess Anne County Court records.  They are incomplete (there was a pesky Civil War that burned them up), but they are fascinating.5

Despite the best efforts of Luke and Elizabeth Hill, the courts were reluctant to pursue the murder-via-witchcraft charges.  The judges, county officials, and even the Governor’s Council dragged their feet at every step.  

At the first court appearance on January 3rd, 1706, Grace didn’t even show up.  This was a strategic mistake, because the court then ordered she be imprisoned in the county jail until the next session.  It also seems that they forgot to charge her with anything.  Oopsie!

At the second court appearance in February, there was a lengthy debate about what to do.  Again, nothing was decided. Perhaps at a loss, the Justices ordered that Grace come back to court in March.  In the meantime, the Sheriff was ordered to summon a jury of women to search Grace’s body for marks and to report their findings.

At the third session on March 7th, the findings of Grace’s search were revealed.  The completely unbiased Jury of Women (headed by Grace’s very first witchcraft accuser, Elizabeth Barnes), declared that they had found at least 2 suspicious marks.  Despite these findings, the court did nothing.  There is no record of a penalty or a dismissal.  Grace probably walked free.

The historical marker near the site of her ducking.

The first episode of Law & Order: Special Witches Unit had ended.  Luke and Elizabeth Hill must have been incandescent with rage.  The local Justices of the Peace were trying to sweep the whole thing under the rug, but the Hills weren’t having it.

Late in March of 1706, Luke Hill petitioned the Governor and his Council.  He explained the Princess Anne County Court’s lack of action, and begged the Attorney General to prosecute Grace Sherwood for her crimes in a higher court.  In April, the Attorney General responded – rather than take up the prosecution himself, he directed the local authorities do the whole thing over again.  And this time, he suggested they charge her with a crime.  And maybe do a real investigation.  For Grace, the whole rodeo was starting over again.  

On May 2nd, the Court cited the Attorney General’s report and ordered that Grace be taken to jail until the next session in June.  They ordered a new Jury of Women to examine her.  They ordered a second Jury of Women to search her house and look for evidence of witchcraft.  And they asked for a Crown Representative to make the case on behalf of the Hills.  (Curiously, this had not already happened.)

On June 6th, Luke Hill testified against Grace.  (Why didn’t he testify before?  His wife was the afflicted one, why didn’t Elizabeth take the stand?)  On June 7th, the Court asked the Sheriff for the results of the new examination and the property search by the two Juries of Women.

He didn’t have them.  The Sheriff had impaneled two different groups of women for the tasks.  They had all refused to participate.  No one was willing to help the court in its dirty work.  Episode two of Law & Order: Special Witches Unit was just as disappointing for the Hills.

Hearing this, the Justices ordered all of the women to be held in Contempt.  A new Jury of Women would be called.  Grace was ordered back to prison until the next court session in July.

On July 5th, the Court reconvened and learned that, once again, no women were willing to join the Jury to examine Grace. 

So there was no new evidence.  The court was stuck in idle.  Again.  At this point, there’s a note of exasperation in the court records.  They had been trying to proceed for six months.  The Attorney General for the Colony of Virginia had ordered them to shit or get off the pot, but there was no compelling evidence in either direction.  The local people weren’t cooperating anymore.  Luke and Elizabeth Hill wouldn’t shut up and go away.  And Grace had been rotting in jail for 2 months.

Grace had had enough.  The Court had had enough.  On July 5th, they struck a bargain.  Dun dun!

Totally Ducked

The Princess Anne County court records ordering Grace Sherwood to be ducked. Courtesy of the Virginia Historical Society.

Therefore it was Ordrd that this Day by her own Consent to be tried in the water by Ducking, but the weather being Rainy and Bad Soe that possibly it might endanger her health it is therefore ordrd that the Sherr request the Justices precisely to appear on wednessday next by tenn of the Clock the Court house and that he Secure the body of the Sd till that time to be forth Coming then to be Dealt wth afore sd.7

This part of the story is a revelation.

When I was a child hearing this story for the first time, this was presented completely differently.  Grace was thrown into the river and she survived by some miracle.  She certainly didn’t consent to be thrown in.  But here, we have evidence that she agreed to this.  We have evidence that the Justices arranged this bit of theatre with her safety in mind. 

The ducking was not her sentence after a trial, the ducking was a bit of pre-trial maneuvering to further establish guilt or innocence, to move her on to a full trial or exonerate her completely.


The court ordered her to be ducked on July 10th, which gave five days notice to everyone in the county who might want to go and watch.  That was enough time for the anticipation to ratchet into the stratosphere.  I wonder – when Grace emerged from the jail to be taken out on the river that day, was she greeted like Charles Manson?  Or did people see her as a victim?

On July 10th, 1706, she was removed from the jail and a procession left the courthouse and headed for a prepared site on the Lynnhaven River.  It is said that huge throngs of people crowded the riverbanks to get a glimpse of the action.

An aerial view of Witch Duck Point today.

For those that couldn’t see at the back of the crowds, it’s easy to imagine a Howard Cosell-type Monday Night Football narration:  “Sherwood is in the boat… the Sheriff makes the handoff… SHERWOOD IS IN THE WATER… SHERWOOD IS IN THE WATER… a big splash… SHE’S FLOATING…SHE’S A WITCH!  SHERWOOD IS A WITCH!”

At this point, just for good measure, the Sheriff apparently beaned Grace with a heavy Bible to see if she’d sink.  She did, rather like anyone else in deep water who gets a ten pound weight chucked at their head.

Once they were sure of the result, they hauled her back to shore and had a council of “five antient weomen” examine her.  They again claimed she had some dark marks that weren’t normal.

The Justices were finally convinced of her guilt.  She was remanded to the Sheriff’s custody and told to await her “Future Tryall.”

There is no record of this future trial.  It’s unclear if the trial happened or if the charges were dismissed.  There is no record of Luke or Elizabeth Hill’s reaction.  

After the ducking, Grace lived 34 more years and was never accused of witchcraft again.


Notes & Sources

1  I used to think this theory was ludicrous (who has the energy to get upset about fashion?), but then I started paying attention to all the modern day grief and violence that accompanies transexuals who wear the “wrong” clothing.  Now this theory doesn’t seem so farfetched.

2  I can’t decide if this is a very early manifestation of BDSM or if someone had a vision of the future and saw Michelle Pfeiffer in Batman.

3 To me, this smacks of paternalism: “Oh these country bumpkins are at it again!  When will they stop?”

4 Though heavily implied, it is never stated outright… Did the assault cause Elizabeth Hill’s miscarriage?  Or did she miscarry after Grace won her day in court?

5 The gears of 18th century justice moved a bit differently.  Instead of appearing before one judge, Grace had to appear before a panel of Justices of the Peace.  These men were prominent local officials, often ship captains or members of the militia, and they convened once a month on behalf of the Crown.  I was surprised that some names were already familiar to me: Adam Thoroughgood (a descendant of the local legend), Richardson, Woodhouse, etc.

6 There are lots of advantages to this.    

  1. She has to strip naked and be examined, possibly more than once.
  2. There was no need for evidence of a crime, because Ghostbusters hadn’t come out yet and nobody would have known to look for pink goo in the subway.
  3. She has to go to court, which is a nuisance and far away from home.  Even if she wins, it still costs her time and money to appear.
  4. You get to testify in court, and let everyone know how horrible she is.  
  5. If she loses, she’s humiliated, fined, maybe jailed, and possibly thrown overboard into a muddy swamp.  She might even die.

7 There was a belief in those days that water – an element of holy baptism – was a pure substance.  Therefore, it would reject a witch and bob her back to the surface.  If Grace were innocent, the water would accept her and she would sink.  Grace popped back to the top of the water like a cork.

Cushing, Jonathan.  Collections of the Virginia Historical and Philosophical Society, vol 1. TW White, 1833.  Google Books.

Hume, Ivor Noel.  “Witchcraft and Evil Spirits.”  Something from the Cellar, Colonial Williamsburg Foundation, 2005, pp. 88-90.  Google Books.

James, Edward W. “Grace Sherwood, the Virginia Witch.” The William and Mary Quarterly, vol. 3, no. 2, 1894, pp. 96–101. JSTOR, JSTOR,

Newman, Lindsey.  “Under an Ill Tongue: Witchcraft and Religion in Seventeenth Century Virginia.”  MA Thesis, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, 2009.

“The Virginia Case of Grace Sherwood, 1706.” Narratives of the Witchcraft Cases, edited by George Lincoln Burr, Charles Scribner & Sons Press, 1914, pp. 433-442.  Google Books.

Witkowski, Monica C. “Grace Sherwood (ca. 1660–1740).” Encyclopedia Virginia. Virginia Foundation for the Humanities, 1 Jan. 2014. Web. 2 Feb. 2018.